Author: Cara has written 429 posts for this blog.

Return to: Homepage | Blog Index

50 Responses

  1. 1
    Thom 3.5.2009 at 12:19 pm |

    Rose and Bernard *better not* be dead. There will be problems if they are.

  2. 3
    ZiaTroyano 3.5.2009 at 12:30 pm |

    Considering how Michael and Walt’s storyline was “resolved”, I wouldn’t be surprised if the writers drop the ball on Rose and Bernard.

    As for Sawyer-Kate-Jack-Juliet-whoever, that’s the only part of Lost that has never ceased to bore me in all these years. I’m not anti-romance. (Desmond and Penny are my people!) But whenever this story comes up, I just don’t care.

  3. 5
    ZiaTroyano 3.5.2009 at 12:43 pm |

    I understand the difference you’re talking about, Cara. For me, it seemed like less effort was put into Michael and Walt’s story arc vs. other folk. I thought sending Michael off the island only to bring him back and blow him up on the freighter was weak, when his story began in a more interesting fashion. And whenever we see Walt, it doesn’t add much to the plot. It’s like the writers are telling you, “By the way, Walt is still around.”

  4. 6
    earlgreyrooibos 3.5.2009 at 12:48 pm |

    I would really like to know what happened with Michael, though. Just sayin’. I like when plot holes get resolved.

    And yeah, the Kate/Sawyer/Juliet/Jack stuff bores me, too. Mostly because I don’t like Juliet’s character and I CANNOT STAND Kate or Jack (it says a lot about the overall story of the show that I love it even though I despise the leading woman and man).

    I wouldn’t mind if the writers just did not resolve the romantic pairings, because I don’t care. I DO care about how they get back to 200-whatever-year-the-present-is. And about how Sayid and Hurley get there. And how/why Ben got beat up. And Rose and Bernard, of course. I just adore them.

    Horace says thanks for saving Amy, now we’re sending you home because you’re not Dharma material. For some reason, Sawyer hates this idea and works on letting them stay longer.

    I just assumed he wanted to do that to wait around for Locke. I mean, would Locke really be able to find them if they were sent to Tahiti?

  5. 8
    Thom 3.5.2009 at 1:04 pm |

    “but they didn’t just disappear off the face of the planet forever and all time until the end of the show.”

    I now have this mental picture of the last episode, where Rose and Bernard walk into a clearing-running into the primary cast. “Where were you guys?! Bernard and I were looking all over the island for you!”

  6. 9
    Davey 3.5.2009 at 1:32 pm |

    I think the Bernard/Rose situation shows the conflict between storytelling and budgeting/scheduling for actors who are only occasionally on the show. For the previous four seasons, they could simply pretend they were somewhere with the extras most of the time, but now they’ve all been killed. And apparently, the actors have other commitments:

    http://www.tvguide.com/news/happened-Rose-34597.aspx

  7. 11
    earlgreyrooibos 3.5.2009 at 2:09 pm |

    I assumed [Michael] died, since he was standing right next to the bomb when it blew up, and since Christian/the Island said “you can go (die) now, Michael,” which is what he wanted all along.

    I still would like for Walt to get some resolution – he doesn’t know his father died, does he? I dunno, I guess it’s not that important, it just grates on me a little that Walt doesn’t know.

    Also, I know this is silly, but I would love for Walt and Vincent to reunite (although Vincent is probably dead?). It’s not important to the plot at all, I’d just love to see it.

  8. 13
    ZiaTroyano 3.5.2009 at 2:42 pm |

    I thought it was odd that Walt didn’t seem that stressed when he talked to John Locke. Even if he had been dreaming about the guy, I would think that Walt would have been peppering John with questions.

  9. 14
    Rachel S. 3.5.2009 at 2:42 pm |

    I saw the Sawyer/Juliet thing coming, but it doesn’t make me like it anymore. My first reaction was “WTF? Are women interchangeable or something?” It just pissed me off. I get that Jack and Sawyer are the dominant male figures, but why do they have to share women? (And why do Juliet and Kate become more alike as the show goes on? Do the writers only know how to write one type of female character?)

  10. 15
    Nikita 3.5.2009 at 3:10 pm |

    Thom
    I almost had tea come out my nose visualizing Rose and Bernard running in during the last episode. Thanks. :)

  11. 16
    E.M. Russell 3.5.2009 at 3:32 pm |

    Did anyone else enjoy the HELL out of this episode? I just thought it was fantastic when Sawyer was all like “Drink my knowledge up!” to Alpert, oh how the tables are turned!

  12. 17
    Superlagirl 3.5.2009 at 3:38 pm |

    I think Rose and Bernard become the skeletons that the survivors found in the caves in the first season. For real.

    And where is 1970s Ben? I thought he grew up on the island. Or maybe that was just another one of his lies. Dammit, Ben. I can’t keep it all straight anymore.

  13. 19
    Superlagirl 3.5.2009 at 3:54 pm |

    Oh! And who was the baby? Anyone we know?

  14. 20
    Thom 3.5.2009 at 4:03 pm |

    “I think the Bernard/Rose situation shows the conflict between storytelling and budgeting/scheduling for actors who are only occasionally on the show. For the previous four seasons, they could simply pretend they were somewhere with the extras most of the time, but now they’ve all been killed. And apparently, the actors have other commitments:”

    Yeah, L. Scott Caldwell does a lot of stage work. The producers said that is the reason she didn’t appear more in the previous four seasons either. But honestly, when Lost is over? I want someone to add her and Sam to their cast. Or base a show around them…as Rose and Bernard or as two totally new characters. If someone makes it, I will watch it!

  15. 21
    earlgreyrooibos 3.5.2009 at 4:15 pm |

    Oh! And who was the baby? Anyone we know?

    You mean the baby that Amy had? Probably too young to be Ben if child-Ben is going to have a 4-story arc this season, but you never know . . .

    I think Rose and Bernard become the skeletons that the survivors found in the caves in the first season. For real.</i.

    That is an EXCELLENT theory. It would make me a little sad, actually, but it still would be a cool way to explain them.

  16. 22
    earlgreyrooibos 3.5.2009 at 4:16 pm |

    Oh wait, Ben wasn’t born on the island. DUH. Lost fail.

  17. 24
    earlgreyrooibos 3.5.2009 at 5:01 pm |

    Faraday was going to be my next guess, but his mother’s name isn’t Amy.

  18. 26
    lyra_silvertongue 3.5.2009 at 5:40 pm |

    I don’t like at all that somehow the 90 days that Sawyer knew Kate are at all comparable to the relationship he’s been building with Juliet for 3 years.

  19. 27
    groovybroad 3.5.2009 at 5:56 pm |

    Not Ben…his story told us he came to the island with his father to work for Dharma. Its the 70′s. Perhaps the baby is not anyone important for the plot.
    Could it possibly be Desmond? Eloise Hawking said the island wasn’t done with him whether he liked it or not…He got angry and said something about her making it sould like he was always meant to be there anyway.

    I don’t know, but Juliet began the show in “present” time, brought to figure out why no pregnant women could give birth on the island, they all died. So…did this baby never happen originally in the first place or did them (Sawyer, Juliette, etc) coming into the 70′s throught the flashes, on the island where they never were originally, actually create this event that was never supposed to happen in the first place/never did happen?

    I don’t know if I explained it right, but in my head it sounded good.

    Also…Ben should be about to kill the Dharma any day now…if they intend to match it correctly. He does it in the 70′s with his dad next to him, in one of the blue vans….that we see ALOT of in this episode…

    Interesting: Horace has never heard of The Black Rock Sawyer was talking about becaue French lady landed 16 years before the present cast…not in the 70′s…so she is not even there yet…

  20. 29
    frau sally benz 3.5.2009 at 6:10 pm |

    I didn’t really like this episode, and was a bit disappointed. When we saw the statue return within the first few minutes, I got so excited! And then the rest was this annoying character development, mushy gushy crap. I mean it was still good, but damn I expected a lot more after the first few minutes.

    Some of the scenes were pretty good though. The Sawyer/Alpert scene was awesome, and when Sawyer called Desmond Plato, I could not stop laughing.

    I don’t care anymore what happens with the love-triangle-turned-square they’ve got going. They had me interested for a while, but now I just want more action. There aren’t many episodes left, relatively speaking, and just so many damn questions still unanswered.

    Even if he had been dreaming about the guy, I would think that Walt would have been peppering John with questions.

    I always thought that after leaving the island the way he did, Walt has learned to not ask any questions. The answers will likely be too messy and too strange.

  21. 30
    frau sally benz 3.5.2009 at 6:11 pm |

    Oh, and they better not kill Sayid or I will lose it.

  22. 31
    groovybroad 3.5.2009 at 6:43 pm |

    Cara, yes you’re right about the Black Rock…I always connected Danielle with it cause she always talked about having to trek 3 miles north of The Black Rock or this or that about the BR…but she is on her way eventually nonetheless…

    Ok, and as far as the pregnant women…this part is still weird because
    Ben brought Juliette to the island for this very reason, where he grew up…if he knew why it happened, meaning he is there in the 70′s…the bomb was the 50′s, right?

    Then why not tell just her that was the problem is so she could actually fix it, if at all? I mean, she knows quite a bit about how long they have been there, Dharma station info, knows Richard, in some of her first episodes she turns off some alarm as well on a fence to keep that black smoke away, just alot of stuff…why keep her out of the loop of the problem she is supposed to be fixing when she knows all this other stuff?

    Yea, not the best episode, but they can’t all be. I liked certain parts.

    And seriously, where is Sayid, Pilot and Sun?

  23. 33
    groovybroad 3.5.2009 at 6:48 pm |

    The first sentence of my last paragraph above is all full of wierdness…and I can’t edit it…:(

    But anyone got any ideas about why Ben went out of his way to stop Locke from killing himself only to flip out and kill him anyway?

    And I thought someone on the show said that whoever turns that wheel can never come back. But Locke saw him lying on that bed as one of the “injured” passengers…I kinda understand how locke was able to come back, but why is Ben able to?

  24. 34
    groovybroad 3.5.2009 at 6:51 pm |

    Ahh, but Ben likes to think he knows everything about the island!
    I would just ask creepy Richard. He’s older than God anyway, he must know.

  25. 35
    acallidryas 3.5.2009 at 10:31 pm |

    groovy- I think that Ben’s the one who said that whoever turns the wheel can’t come back (to convince Locke to let him turn it), so there’s no reason to believe it.

    And as far as Walt’s storyline, I wondered if maybe one of the reasons they skipped ahead three years was so that they could bring Walt back without it being weird that he looked a few years older.

  26. 37
    Jill 3.6.2009 at 1:23 am | *

    The baby can’t be Ben because we know Ben was born off the island. It can’t be Faraday because we know who Faraday’s mother is. I think the baby is possibly Desmond.

    And I’m with superlagirl that “Adam and Eve” (the skeletons from Season 1) are Rose and Bernard. They were found with a black and white rock in front of them, which is a bit… literal… but it would make sense.

    I just want them to bring back Libby and stop with the stupid Jack/Sawyer/Kate/Juliet drama. Juliet also needs to stop talking in that therapist voice all the time.

    Anyone else happy to see Sawyer back with glasses on reading books? He is teh hotness in those scenes.

  27. 38
    Jill 3.6.2009 at 1:24 am | *

    Cara, the preview is very traumatic re: Sayeed.

  28. 39
    Jill 3.6.2009 at 1:25 am | *

    Also, sad that grown-up Walt is not a very good actor. He was so good as a kid!

  29. 40
    Sid 3.6.2009 at 1:43 am |

    Sorry, this bugs me to no end, since I share his name but his name is Sayyid pronounced like “Say id” (short, flat i) not Sayeed, which has a different meaning entirely. (I’m aware that everyone on the show makes the same mistake)

  30. 41
    Kyle 3.6.2009 at 4:48 am |

    Anybody else think it was weird that Sawyer gave a fake name? They already knew it was in the past, and that nobody would know who they were. Also, when all the others told Horace to talk to Sawyer, what did they refer to him as? Our captain? James? Why not the regular Sawyer? It seemed like a weak reason just so they could play up the first few minutes pretending that Sawyer and the rest weren’t part of Dharma.

  31. 42
    Natalia 3.6.2009 at 6:22 am |

    I find myself enjoying most episodes where Kate doesn’t play a central part. I think her character is pretty blah, and I constantly forget why I’m supposed to care. The other points of the square, however – Jack, Juliet, and, most of all, Sawyer, I liiike.

    The statue was definitely the most exciting part of this episode, though. I squealed delightedly. At least they didn’t totally forget the statue.

    Count me in among the people who desperately need Rose & Bernard back, in the meantime.

  32. 43
    Superlagirl 3.6.2009 at 8:29 am |

    I’m not sure the baby is Desmond. The baby was born in 77, and the survivors meet Desmond in 2004, which would make him 27. He strikes me as older than that. Then again, I’m not very good judge of age.

  33. 45
    Sid 3.6.2009 at 11:02 am |

    Yes, the name has many spellings and transliterations across different Arabic dialects, however, its pronunciation is still with the short i, not the elongated “i” that everyone else on the show pronounces it with. It is distinguished from the pronounciation of Ceaser’s portrayer Said Taghmaoui, which is indeed pronounced Sayeed.

  34. 46
    ZiaTroyano 3.6.2009 at 12:49 pm |

    But anyone got any ideas about why Ben went out of his way to stop Locke from killing himself only to flip out and kill him anyway?

    And I thought someone on the show said that whoever turns that wheel can never come back. But Locke saw him lying on that bed as one of the “injured” passengers

    I’m thinking this stuff ties into the “leadership of the Others/island” thing. Christian Shephard told Locke the other week that he was supposed to turn the wheel, not Ben. Ben told John about not being able to come back. But he lies so often, who knows if that’s true? And Eloise Hawking might be able to help Locke in a way that Ben doesn’t want her to.

  35. 47
    Superlagirl 3.6.2009 at 1:26 pm |

    “And as a random note, no matter how old he is, he’s still super hot! So long as he has a beard of some sort.”

    Agreed. But the real question is, long hair or short? I’m so conflicted!

  36. 48
    Kendra 3.8.2009 at 4:44 pm |

    “Will Faraday stop looking at toddler Charlotte all longingly like a damn pedophile?”

    LOLing. Hence grown-up Charlotte’s “Crazy man who scared me and told me to never come back” comment.

  37. 49
    K 3.12.2009 at 10:53 pm |

    Sawyer took the name of an old con. but does anybody remember the episode where Hurley and Sawyer finds the old blue van? The one they fix up? It had a 6 pack of beer and a skeleton wearing a Darmah suit wth the name Laflur. Makes you wonder. We have also seen Horaces’ skeleton as well.

  38. 50
    Kestra 3.14.2009 at 3:21 pm |

    Last week’s episdoe, LaFleur -
    Just after the scene where Sawyer convinces Juliet to stay on the island rather than take the sub, and just after the screen shows the words, “Three years later”, you see Saywer walking to pick a flower for Juliet. Right around that time, in the background just for a few seconds it looks like they show young Ben sitting on the bench all by himself.
    Did anyone else notice this?

Comments are closed.