Black. Male. Feminist?

This is a guest post from G.D. at PostBourgie.

My sister, grandmother and me, circa 1983.

Over at The Root, Byron Hurt has a candid piece about how watching the fraught interaction between his parents as a kid helped plant the seeds for his adult embrace of feminism:

Feminist writings about patriarchy, racism, capitalism and structural sexism resonated with me because I had witnessed firsthand the kind of male dominance they challenged. I saw it as a child in my home and perpetuated it as an adult. Their analysis of male culture and male behavior helped me put my father’s patriarchy into a much larger social context, and also helped me understand myself better.

You’ll have to forgive me for how jumbled/discursive/TMI this is going to read, but this has agitated a lot of stuff I’ve been thinking about and was frankly saving for a much neater Mother’s Day post.

My own, very flawed feminism is also rooted in my childhood, albeit in circumstances very different from Hurt’s. His father’s presence was inescapable. Mine was imperceptible.

And I wasn’t an outlier: there just weren’t a lot of fathers doing the quotidian work of parenting in my South Philadelphia neighborhood, as if all the adult black men had agreed to go into hiding. And so the teachers; the parents who yelled at us to come inside when it got dark, and who organized the church trips, camps and block parties, were almost always black women. My grandmother scooped me up from soccer practice. My mom taught me the rules of football and tied my ties. My aunt helped me with my long division. Her daughter taught me how to shoot free throws. When something broke, one of these women fixed it.

None of these were feminist acts in and of themselves, and those women would never have identified as feminists, but they were (and remain) giants to me. And I was living in a world, albeit not the one they probably would have preferred, in which the traditional gender roles were queered. My world was largely populated by black women who were fantastically smarter and more competent than I was. That didn’t forestall my fantastically awkward attempts to slide into some ill-fitting molds of masculinity, and I still bought into all those gendered hierarchies even though they were especially abstract for me. But all of this hobbled my capacity to see the eventual assumption of gender roles as foregone or necessary conclusions, and stoked a lingering skepticism of the supposed truths on which they rested.

The theory — Patricia Hill Collins, Judith Butler, etc. — would all come later, in college. But the ground was already fertile. Ta-Nehisi Coates wrote about the roving packs of young dudes in B-more who dumped on other young dudes, with no real pretext. So it was where I grew up, where those cats felt less like my contemporaries and more like a capricious force of nature. (I’ve said before that the reason folks at my high school tried hard not to get detention wasn’t because they were well-behaved kids, but because detention meant walking the five North Philly blocks to the subway on your lonesome.) You learned to look over your shoulder, to take the long way to wherever you were going. And if you got caught out there — and most of us did, at some point — that was your fault. You were slipping, actin’ like it can’t happen.

I remember my mom cautioned both my twin sister and me as teenagers to be on point, but there was a different shading to the warnings she gave my sister. They were: Don’t leave your drink unattended. Make sure your girls know where you are. My sister, it was assumed, was going to have someone say some slick shit to her, to hop in her personal space, to put their hands on her as she passed. The company of a friend wasn’t going to stop it. Nothing was. She was going to bear the responsibility for these transgressions when they inevitably happened. Others would have said my sister wasn’t cautious enough, or asked her what she was wearing, or why she was where she was. The response would always be to ascertain what she did wrong, how she should have known better, how she got caught slipping.

Our experiences were subtly, profoundly different, but they were mundane, and their ordinariness belied their injustice. To grow up like this meant developing a certain resignation about the specter of violence, and often — perversely — feeling personally responsible when something ugly happened. But I didn’t have a way to think about these things until I learned about feminism. The first time I heard the term “sexual terrorism,” then, I finally had a name to something I’d always fundamentally known. The great irony was that I was having these realizations and entertaining these conversations for the first time on a suburban college campus where I actually felt completely safe.

But this wider berth still didn’t extend to my female friends. One summer while I was on campus, a friend of mine called me after she went to a bar with her sorority sisters and woke up the next day in a bare bed in an empty dorm room with no idea how she got there. What followed next — the police report, the rape kit, the feeling that her friends abandoned her, and their accusations that she should have been more careful about her drinking — was all horrifying, and I knew I’d never even have to consider or live through anything like it. This world was happening all around me in plain sight, and I was incapable of perceiving it even as I was undoubtedly abetting it.

There were plenty of other moments. It took years before one of my dearest friends, my ace, could tell me he was gay. I found out accidentally through a mutual female friend. There was a long stretch — several years — when he and I didn’t talk about it, when I knew and he didn’t know I knew. As tight as he and I were, I was a heterosexual dude, and he had ample reason to worry about my rejecting him. When he finally told me, it was anticlimactic and we were both relieved. I jokingly chided him for not telling me sooner. But I thought about all the arguments we had about hip-hop and politics and basketball and women — safe dude shit — and how we’d forged a deep, real supportive friendship in which he was still precluded from telling me about how he felt about the people he dated and loved; he’d helped me tread water during some pretty rough times and yet I didn’t feel comfortable telling him that I loved him for it. Because he was a dude. Clearly, we were doing this all wrong.

Although I do it, I still don’t feel totally comfortable calling myself a feminist, both because it has the feel of appropriation and because I am a deeply imperfect vessel. I am routinely very, very dumb about this shit as a heterosexual dude — with all the tunnel vision and privilege that attends that location. The relationship those realities have to my blackness is a muddled one; sometimes they’re independent, sometimes they act in concert. But if growing up black and poor and male provided an unlikely bridge to anti-sexist thinking, so has feminism complicated the way I think about blackness and class. The way I perform masculinity is wrapped in the way I understand blackness, and vice versa. Their parameters are constantly evolving in my head, which means constantly reconsidering the way I orient myself to the world. This is rarely comfortable stuff. But it shouldn’t be.

17 comments for “Black. Male. Feminist?

  1. March 20, 2011 at 8:19 pm

    Thanks to the writer for this thought-provoking piece. I’ve often reflected on how all the different intersecting identities we all possess shape our understanding of the philosophies and political agendas we choose to adopt.

    I know that for me, it’s very difficult to situate myself for a variety of reasons. For one, although this proud Latina can cook up a storm of arroz con gandules and can speak Spanish fluently, I have all of the physical cues of a white woman. I am often mistaken for Italian, Mediterranean, and sometimes Middle Eastern. Given that I’m not easily racializable, I have alot of white privilege I wouldn’t otherwise have if I was darker-skinned, if my hair wasn’t straight, or my features less European. So, even though I’ve had awful, traumatic experiences of racism and prejudice that did happen to me, I often feel that in the context of an anti-racist dialogue, I straddle the boundary between the one who has experienced, and the ally who sympathizes.

    In a similar way, in terms of my sexuality and gender, I’m a cisgender woman in a relationship with a cisgender man. Most people make the assumption that I’m straight. I tend to dress femme, and though I have a short haircut, it’s never been something that has made people question my sexuality. So even though I do identify as queer, and I am attracted to people of all genders, when I attend LGBTQ events and discussions, I’m again straddling that line: the subject and the ally.

    Don’t be surprised if this ends up as a blog post over at Scribbles & Sonnets. This really got me thinking.

  2. March 20, 2011 at 10:16 pm

    Thank you.

    I can’t scrape up enough brain cells to make a more constructive comment so heartfelt and brief will have to do, but as an aside if anyone is interested in yet more writing from the black male feminist perspective (I personally can’t get enough of it), I recommend Gary L. Lemons’ Black Male Outsider: Teaching as a Pro-feminist Man : A Memoir, which also includes a pedagogical perspective. It was first cited to me by someone on Feministe who was a former student of Lemons, and it did not disappoint.

    Thank you again, G.D., for this post.

  3. March 20, 2011 at 11:20 pm

    Thanks for writing this, it was really interesting and I’m thinking about what you’ve said. I’m hopping over to check out your website now; I’m sure it’ll be as thought provoking as this piece. Sorry if this sounds kind of generic and not thoughtful, but I do want to say thanks for a piece from a Black male feminist perspective. It’s not a voice I hear a lot, so I’m really interested in hearing/reading more about your experience.

  4. Geo
    March 21, 2011 at 1:49 am

    Very, very helpful – writing! Thanks for allowing us all to read it. Byron Hurt – is (already) noted on A Men’s Project (my link here) – as a national/international speaker- other individuals (such as the author of this) or websites related to Men and Sexism/Racism and similar are Always welcome – to get added to A Men’s Project to help make it more relevant. Thanks!

  5. March 21, 2011 at 2:41 am

    This is a really great article. Thank you for sharing it. I think you really hit the nail on the head with the how your experiences have informed your views, instead of the other way around. Good stuff, I’m going to go read your blog now :)

  6. Medea
    March 21, 2011 at 4:12 am

    Thanks, that was great.

  7. Kaija
    March 21, 2011 at 6:48 am

    Thank you so much for this heartfelt and eloquent piece. As others have said, it is definitely thoughtprovoking and echoes some of the realizations and awarenesses that I have developed about racism and other identities as an outgrowth of my own experiences as a woman and a feminist. I also especially liked the observation that some of the “click” moments occurred once out of the place where you grew up…as was the case for me as well. I’m grateful for the broader view and scope of feminism when it is truly intersectional and this piece is a wonderful example of that.

  8. Tawny
    March 21, 2011 at 9:12 am

    Thank you for writing this. =) I’m at work, so I can’t say much, but I really appreciated reading your experiences, and it is always good to know that there are hetero dudes out there actually empathizing and understanding.

    It makes all those times when one of them is doing the opposite easier to bear.

  9. Katie
    March 21, 2011 at 11:33 pm

    This was great. Sent it to a friend who has a really similar history, and it was meaningful for us both in different ways.

  10. Li
    March 22, 2011 at 2:41 am

    After the day I just had, it was really amazing to come home to an article like this. I’m not really able to do a longer response right now, but I really appreciate reading about another feminist/pro-feminist man’s experience.

  11. March 22, 2011 at 3:57 am

    Why is it that any post by a man expressing himself as a strong feminist ally invariably receives thanks for writing it rather than discussion?

    It’s a great post. I find the answers that come up when you ask “When / how did you become a feminist?” endlessly interesting.

    But I do wonder – and I trust G.D. would react to that with thoughtfulness (and maybe another great post) about the politics of a man writing about feminism on a feminist blog.

  12. Emily
    March 22, 2011 at 6:54 am

    So many of the male voices in this space are antagonistic commenters. I think it’s really valuable to have contructive thoughtful posts from a male perspective. I love the way GD describes how his personal experiences made feminism make sense to him. I love hearing peoples personal stories and journeys. I think it’s one of the best ways to get people to see different perpectives, make new connections, enrich their theory and activism.

    Despite being female I have mostly always felt safe in my neighborhood, in my schools. I know that a lot of that is privilege, and maybe some of it is denial, but GDs vivid description living as a young person with the fear of being targeted for basically no reason – that bit definitely has me thinking.

  13. Lauren
    March 22, 2011 at 7:34 am

    Yonmei: But I do wonder – and I trust G.D. would react to that with thoughtfulness (and maybe another great post) about the politics of a man writing about feminism on a feminist blog.

    Yonmei, I’m the founder of Feministe and this used to be my personal blog. There is a long history over this blog’s 10+ years of attempting inclusiveness on many levels and inviting voices that would inspire thought and discussion outside of our norms, including having male voices participate. This piece happened to be recommended by me as a possible guest post when I saw it and loved it on PB (I’m a long-time reader of their blog, which is great BTW). Incidentally, the mods always welcome guest posts and posts can be recommended by writing feministe at gmail. But I don’t see any reason why another post dissecting the usefulness of men writing about feminism is necessary unless one believes feminism is a woman-only movement.

  14. Pingback: What We Missed
  15. March 24, 2011 at 9:48 am

    Great post. If you’re looking for more to read, I’d recommend Mark Anthony Neal’s book New Black Man. He offers a practical theory of Black male feminism that was really refreshing to read. He also talks a great deal about parenting daughters and brings up some of the issues you mention.

Comments are closed.