Author: has written 15 posts for this blog.

Return to: Homepage | Blog Index

11 Responses

  1. Greg
    Greg August 2, 2011 at 11:27 pm |

    Number 2 isn’t incremental. Once the regulations take full effect, free birth control for every woman in America will be as big a deal as the invention of the pill and Roe vs. Wade.

    In addition it’s a killer wedge issue for us. The next president would have the ability to eliminate it with the stroke of a pen, so there will be enormous pressure from the anti-choicers for the Republican candidates to vow to strike that rule down. But once you give voters free stuff, you can never take it away without a huge fight.

    Another plus, it’s been hard to convince people that the anti-choice movement is really about restricting women’s sexual autonomy, and that birth control itself is at risk. Once a Republican presidential candidate is on record saying he’ll take away free birth control to appease his party’s base, it will become real for a lot of women. Any congressional candidate who runs on repealing Obamacare would open him- or herself up to the same attack.

  2. Tori
    Tori August 2, 2011 at 11:31 pm |

    2) Does anyone have knowledge as to whether insurers must cover birth control for non-contraceptive purposes without copays? I realize there’s all kinds of privilege tied up in me being concerned about me being concerned about my generic-tier copay, but — When I have my doubts about how well these pills are doing their off-label job, it’s sometimes more health-conscious for me to find other uses for that money.

  3. ch
    ch August 3, 2011 at 4:25 am |

    Greg, it’s not free birth control for *every* woman in America. It’s free birth control for every *insured* woman in America. It’s still a big, awesome thing, but there are a hell of a lot of uninsured women out there who are still out of luck.

  4. Rhoanna
    Rhoanna August 3, 2011 at 8:37 am |

    It’s also only for women with insurance plans that aren’t grandfathered. While that number will decline over time, not every woman with insurance will be able to get free birth control come 2013. One article says that only 34 million women between age 18 and 65 will be covered initially.

  5. Iris
    Iris August 3, 2011 at 11:26 am |

    “Kickass lesbian heroes.”

    I loved this story. They are truly inspirational.

    Re: birth control…

    What a strange society we live in – a big deal to provide women (who already have health insurance) with no cost birth control.
    And still some people will fight it as though someone else has the right to monitor women’s reproductive choices. And we give these people a legitimate voice in other people’s sexuality because of religion.

    Something really fucked up about that.

    Greg:
    Another plus, it’s been hard to convince people that the anti-choice movement is really about restricting women’s sexual autonomy, and that birth control itself is at risk. Once a Republican presidential candidate is on record saying he’ll take away free birth control to appease his party’s base, it will become real for a lot of women. Any congressional candidate who runs on repealing Obamacare would open him- or herself up to the same attack.

    Women are already aware that restricting birth control is effectively denying them sexual autonomy. Believe me, it’s already real for the vast majority of women in this country. I’m not following your logic which says first you must give it to them, then threaten to take it away, so that they’ll know they’re getting screwed.

    It’s not really free either – you must be covered by insurance. And, still, some insurance won’t cover it right away. That’s not free. The former is a benefit and the latter is just plain sad.

    Women choosing when and if they practice birth control is a basic human right – not a political platform.

  6. Bitter Scribe
    Bitter Scribe August 3, 2011 at 12:49 pm |

    A commenter at Sadly, No! made a good point about that lesbian couple: In situations like this, it’s often a liberal, leftist Godless type who performs a heroic rescue, while the heat-packing macho conservative types are nowhere to be found.

  7. DouglasG
    DouglasG August 3, 2011 at 2:00 pm |

    I entirely agree about the Incredulous Federal Judge. One does not see such every day; it takes a bit of doing.

  8. Greg
    Greg August 3, 2011 at 4:44 pm |

    It will eventually be free for everyone. Once health care reform kicks in, practically everyone will have health insurance, and most plans get renewed often enough that it will apply to upwards of 95% of women in a few years.

    Iris: Women are already aware that restricting birth control is effectively denying them sexual autonomy. Believe me, it’s already real for the vast majority of women in this country. I’m not following your logic which says first you must give it to them, then threaten to take it away, so that they’ll know they’re getting screwed.blockquote>

    I don’t mean denying birth control; I’m talking about the broader anti-choice agenda. Too many people take the anti-choicers at their word that their opposition to abortion is about saving babies, and think pro-choicers are hysterical when they say that they’re coming for birth control next. It’s easy to demonize and stigmatize abortion because not everyone gets them, and those who do keep it a secret.

    We need to decisively win the debate on women’s sexual autonomy to win the abortion issue, but we can’t even have that debate because anti-choicers use the “baby-killing/fetal personhood” debate as a smokescreen. This rule allows us to have that fight from a position of strength.

    Once everyone, or practically everyone, has free birth control, the debate over this regulation is a debate over taking it away. People are generally loss-averse; even though nothing logically changes about the pros and cons of this regulation, you’ll see a lot more people opposing repealing it than supporting enacting it. Partly that because only political nerds know about the debate now, but once it fully takes effect, everyone will know that birth control is free.

    Iris: Women choosing when and if they practice birth control is a basic human right – not a political platform.

    That’s the way it should be, I agree. But that’s one of the steps on the road to making sure that reproductive rights are as basic and untouchable as women’s suffrage or the civil rights act. It’s like that quote, “First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.”

  9. Iris
    Iris August 5, 2011 at 10:46 am |

    Had to share the following video. Thanks to Planned Parenthood for their celebration of health insurance covered birth control.

  10. katrina_iskierka
    katrina_iskierka August 8, 2011 at 7:39 pm |

    I don’t have internet access at home and I tend to have three day periods where I miss the live-ness aspect of new posts and dialogues on Feministe since I clicked a link to “find” it more than a month and less than three months ago.

    So I’ve been scrolling throug all these thoughts (of bloggers and posters of comments) and emotions, seeing what has gone on since last week, and I got to this post.

    I went to church on Sunday where we had a discussion and the leader asked us to recall something recent that had occurred in the world in the past two weeks that filled us with happiness. When it was my turn to speak, I told her I could only think of Norway. I could think of nothing positive. I got to “kickass lesbian heroes” and I was just ready to start bawling, it made me so happy. I am in a public library, so I guess I’m cis-”manning up.” Just a sniffle and some quiet tears. Happy!

Comments are closed.